Home → Leadership
One-on-Ones: An Early Warning System, Not a Status Meeting
"How is it going?" — "Fine." "Anything blocking you?" — "No, all good." The slot was thirty minutes; we finished in eleven. Both of us felt relieved. That relief is exactly the problem.
- A 1:1 is not a status meeting. Work status is already on the board; spending thirty minutes on it is waste.
- The agenda belongs to them. If you speak less than a third of the time, the ratio is right.
- "How is it going?" always returns "fine". Narrow the question or you will not get an answer.
- Reschedule, never cancel. Two cancellations say "this is not important" louder than any words.
What "early warning" actually means
Bad news in an engineering team rarely arrives suddenly. It accumulates for months and then lands on your desk one Tuesday as a resignation letter. Before that letter there are usually dozens of signals: no longer joining debates, review comments shrinking to one line, "I don't mind either way" becoming a habit.
The 1:1 exists to collect those signals. Thirty minutes a week, regular, never cancelled. The measure is simple: how many days late does bad news reach you? If the answer is months, your 1:1s are not working — having them on the calendar changes nothing.
Why everyone says "fine"
Because "how is it going" costs nothing to answer. It is closed, broad and polite, so the answer comes back polite. And the person across from you is doing a calculation: "if I complain, do I become the person who complains?" As long as that calculation is running, the answer will not change.
Narrow the question and everything shifts. A narrow question requires thinking, and a thinking person says real things.
- How is it going?
- Anything blocking you?
- Are you happy?
- Do you need help?
All closed; all have a safe answer: "fine", "no".
- What slowed you down most this week?
- Which piece of work from last month would you refuse to do again?
- If you were me, what would you change first?
- Is there something you thought about raising and then decided not to?
All narrow. "Fine" does not fit any of them.
From the field: where eleven-minute 1:1s end
I ran weekly 1:1s with the quietest engineer on the team for six months. All of them were short, all of them produced "fine". In the seventh month he resigned. One sentence from that conversation stayed with me:
"For four months I only fixed bugs. Every new piece of work went to someone else. Saying that out loud would have sounded like complaining, so I didn't."
Nobody hid anything. I had been asking the wrong question, and he was under no obligation to answer a question I never asked. Worse, I already had the information — it was sitting in Jira as four months of bug tickets, and I had never looked.
Since then I go into 1:1s prepared: five minutes looking at what the person closed in the last month. Those five minutes turn "how is it going" into "you have been mostly fixing bugs for a month now — is that your choice?" The difference between the two questions is six months of silence.
A three-question skeleton
I tried long agenda templates; none of them survived. Three questions did.
"What slowed you down most this week?" The answer is usually a system, not a person: a broken test environment, a review nobody picks up, another team that does not reply. Those are your job; they are being told to you because the person cannot fix them alone.
Once a month is enough. "What do you want to be doing a year from now?" If you never ask it, you will read the answer in a resignation letter. If you do ask, you have a direction to work with — even when you cannot always deliver it.
The first time you ask, nothing comes back. That is normal. By the third time it starts to. And when it does, there is exactly one correct response: take notes without defending yourself.
Small rules that decide everything
- Reschedule, don't cancel. Cancelling says "unimportant"; rescheduling says "important, but not today". The difference is large on the receiving end.
- Take notes; don't trust your memory. Remembering this month what was said last month is the cheapest and strongest way to make someone feel heard.
- Don't sacrifice it in a crisis week. The week you need it most is exactly the week it gets dropped first.
- Walking works too. A lot of what never gets said in a meeting room gets said in the coffee queue.
Checklist
- Did I look at what this person did in the last month?
- Did I open my notes from last time — did I promise anything?
- Whose agenda is this? (If it is mine, why?)
- Is at least one of my questions narrow and concrete?
- How many of the last three did I cancel?
- When did I last hear bad news from this person? (Never is not a good sign.)
Conclusion
A 1:1 is not established by putting thirty minutes on a calendar. There is only one proof that it exists: people bring you bad news early instead of late.
A team where everyone says "fine" every week is not a healthy team. It is a quiet one.